Testimonials | Hoosiers in Paradise

Always Wanted to Try This Place

After 8years We Finally Tried Hoosiers. Although It Was Not Recommended That We Go There. Boy Were They Wrong. Best Tenderloin I Have Ever Had. It Is A Thick Nicely Breaded Sandwich That Can Be Shared By Two People If You Want. We Also Got The Loaded Potatoe Skins. There Are Only 4, But That Is Because They Are 2 Huge Potatoes Cut In Half. They Are Good. All The Food Was Super Hot And Beer Was Cold. Nice Street View If You Sit Outside. A Bunch Of Decorations Inside From Indiana Public Service Department And Ball Teams. We Will Be Back And Will Recommend This Place To Everyone. Good Job!

Best Place for Indiana Sports and Food

Awesome Service, Food And Atmosphere!! Just Like Back Home Except The Weather. Love The Hospitality And People Who Frequent The Place. Great Times. Great Job Mark!!

Hoosiers in Paradise

This Was Our First Stop On Our Vacation, We Stopped In To Watch A Game With Some Other Hoosiers From Indiana. This Is An Upstairs Sports Bar And Restaurant. Their Food Is Really Good. I Ordered The Ahi Tuna Sandwich With A Side Of Their Homemade Chips. The Tuna Was Cooked Perfectly And Served With Wasabi On The Side. The Chips Come With Horseradish Mayo Dipping Sauce. It Was Delicious. They Also Have Fabulous Mojitos Plus Buckets Of Beer. We Stop Here Every Time We’re In Fort Myers Beach. It’s A Fun Place With Indoor And Outdoor Seating. Lots Of Games On Various TVs

Great Hoosier Tenderloin

If You Like To Taste Meat, Then This Tenderloin Is For You. Enough To Split And Enjoy. Potato Skins Are Awesome, They Actually Cut A Whole Potatoes In Half To Make Them. It's On The Second Floor, But They Have An Elevator If You Require One. Neat Indiana Memorabilia Around The Restaurant. Great Food For All Ages. A Definite Must Try.

Great Staff Great Food!

A Friend And I Visited On A Haunted Pub Crawl One Night And Were Impressed With The View, The Staff, And The Convenient Location. We Decided To Try The Food The Next Day. Excellent, Varied Menu. We Enjoyed A Good Burger, Great Onion Rings, And Freshly Brewed Ice Tea. We Will Go Back To Try Something Else On The Menu. The Best Staff On The Beach! Bryan (Brian?) Was Attentive And Friendly. Would Recommend To Others!!!

Best Cheeseburger on The Island

Great Little Place With A Balcony Type View. I Had The Cheeseburger And Fries. I've Had Cheeseburgers On The Beach Before But To Me This One Is The Best I Had. The Steak Fries Were Great Too. Friendly Service By Brian The Bartender And The Kitchen Staff Came Out To Ask How Things Were. Fantastic Place, As A Beach Local I Highly Recommend This Place. It Is An Indiana Hoosiers Bar So I Have To Close This Review With BOILER UP!! LOL

Great Place Great Location

I Used To Not Care Too Much For This Place, But Done Recent Remodeling And Some Open-mindedness On My Part Has Changed My Views A Bit. Although I Maintain That I Could Show Them What A True Hoosier Tenderloin Should Really Be, Other Menu Items Have Raised My Opinion Of The Place. You’ve Won Me Over!

Best BLT Ever!

My Wife Susan And I Visited Here For Lunch One Wednesday Afternoon. Brian Behind The Bar Provided Excellent Service For Us, As My Wife Has Shellfish Allergies And He Alerted Us To The Fact That All Fried Food Was Cooked In One Fryer. He Then Suggested The Broccoli Slaw As A Side Item For My Wife's BLT. My Wife Says The BLT Was The Best She Has Ever Had In Her Life And Broccoli Slaw Was Incredible. I Had The Cheeseburger And It Was Delicious! Also, They Carry Sun King Cream Ale (brewed In Indiana) On Tap! Yummy!

Amazing

Awesome Place...delicious Food...fantastic Owner/staff. They Allowed Us To Stream A Dayton Flyer Basketball Game On Their Big TV. So Grateful We Were Able To Watch Our Team! Put This Place On Your FMB Go To....you Will Be Happy 😊

A Hidden Gem!

My Family And I Just Got Back From A Week In FMB And Our Only Regret Is That We Didn't Stop In To Hoosiers Sooner. It's An Easy Place To Overlook On The Main Drag But We All Agreed It Was "our Kind Of Place"

Our Server Brian Was Outstanding And We Were Lucky Enough To Have Him Each Time We Stopped In. (each Of Our Last 3 Days!). He Was Great At His Job, Had Excellent Recommendations On Food And Drinks, And We Enjoyed Talking To Him. As For The Menu, It's Amazing. Great Down Home Selections Of What I Would Call Comfort Food. The Pork Loin Sandwich Was The Bomb, And Can Be Ordered A Variety Of Ways To Suit You (drenched In The Winger Sauce...delicious!) Everyone From Kids (they Want More Chips) To Grandparents Enjoyed This Place Through And Through. It's A Great Spot To Catch There Sunset Too! Looking Forward To Our Next Visit